Monday, May 7, 2007

What the...

So, I stumble upon Wikinews, to read an article. Then I ran onto something... well, odd. The title of that page says it all:

This is for rants about the article. If you wish to point out a problem in the article (e.g. factual error etc), please use its normal talk page.

What the... ?

~~~~

Sunday, May 6, 2007

Extensions that should be shipped by default

So I've been transwikiing the crap out of Meta recently. Part of that is so we can build a decent, self-contained website on MediaWiki.org. The last thing to be brought over was the MediaWiki Installation Guide. It is still in "transwiki triage", for lack of a better term, but it is more-or-less usable.

We'll see what we can do with it. But if we can do something similar to what we did with extensions, then I'm expecting to drool already. :) The latest invention (by Duesentrieb of dewiki fame) is the Extension Matrix, which includes info about every extension documented on MediaWiki.org... :)

Keeping with the extensions theme, there are a few extensions that *every* MediaWiki installation should have. These extensions are incredibly useful, and include functionality that has become expected of MediaWiki end users. Hopefully someone will decide to merge these extensions somehow into the MediaWiki core, so they don't have to be downloaded individually:

require_once( "extensions/Renameuser/SpecialRenameuser.php" );
require_once( "extensions/ParserFunctions/ParserFunctions.php" );
require_once( "extensions/Filepath/SpecialFilepath.php" );
require_once( "extensions/CheckUser/CheckUser.php");
require_once( "extensions/Makesysop/SpecialMakesysop.php" );
require_once( "extensions/Cite/Cite.php" );
require_once( "extensions/CategoryTree/CategoryTree.php" );
require_once( "extensions/Newuserlog/Newuserlog.php" );
require_once( "extensions/Contributors/Contributors.php" );

and of course...

require_once( "extensions/Poem/Poem.php" );

Heh. ;)

One notable exception is this one:

require_once( "extensions/Oversight/HideRevision.php");

Oversight should not be installed in new installations of MediaWiki. Why? Because it will collide with the current work to implement rev_deleted and cause unnecessary issues. Rev_deleted is due for deployment sometime after MediaWiki 1.10.0 is released, and is quite exciting. See the Gallery for some pretty screenshots... :)

~~~~

Friday, May 4, 2007

MediaWiki installation instructions moved

MediaWiki's installation instructions were once located in Meta. Not anymore. I moved all of them to MediaWiki.org today...

They still need to be verified and updated, but any beta-testers of the old instructions would be very welcome.

See http://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Manual:Installation and http://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Manual:OS_specific_help for the pages that were moved. Please poke us on #mediawiki or on the MediaWiki Project Forum to resolve them.

Happy editing!

~~~~

Thursday, May 3, 2007

Spam is yum?

Well, David Gerard has written a very nice piece about the recent "controversy" over the InterWiki map. I agree with him, but I am unsure about one assertion he made.

"Pagerank is not a consideration for Wikipedia — it contributes nothing to the project of writing an encyclopedia. This is why SEOs and Googlemancers find it so hard to find anyone at Wikipedia or Wikimedia who cares." - David

Pagerank is indeed not a consideration for Wikipedia. It is not something your average editor thinks about when removing "boobies" from [[George W. Bush]]. However, was that true in the past? Google et al. obviously accounted for a huge amount of our incoming traffic. Actually, I'd dare say all of it. And we obviously wouldn't have written anything if no one was going to read it... so, without Pagerank, would there be so many editors? Would Wikipedia, with all of its flaws, be the entity it is today?

That makes for a very interesting line of thought, but I guess the question has become the following: Have we matured as a website enough that we don't need to be plastered all over the top of Google's search results? Have we gotten to the point where people don't look first at Google, but search immediately within Wikipedia? Does anyone have the stats about that? What would be the raw effect of nofollow on our popularity?

Now, from the editor's point of view: I sure love to have an FA I worked on as the top hit in Google. It makes me at least have the impression that I've done something productive. So, does it mean that I write for Google? Does it mean that I care about Pagerank, and the impact that it could have on the amount of readers our articles have? Does it mean that indirectly, the amount of readers I have is an enticement that causes users to produce more content?

...

...

*crickets chirp*

...

...

No, not really. Free content would continue to exist, whether it is at the top of my bookshelf, or the top of the results in a search engine. Regardless of anytihng, people do, and will continue to, read Wikipedia. It is nice to have many more people reading my work as a result of Google's algorithms, but it really isn't the reason I write here. So... no, I guess I don't disagree with David's conclusion. I don't care.

~~~~

Saturday, April 7, 2007

And the curtain finally rises...

Tito's note: This is the fourth in a series of articles about the Version 1.0 Editorial Team in the English Wikipedia.

As I wrote in my previous post, assuming there were no last minute hitches, the Version 0.5 CD should would go on sale on March 26. However, there were a few snags that delayed publication until now. Thankfully, those final obstacles are now a thing of the past, and the long-awaited goal of the Version 1.0 Editorial Team has been accomplished: A CD containing an offline, static version of Wikipedia is available to customers today, thanks to Linterweb.

Our release counts of 1964 articles, which span a variety of subjects, from Art to Zeus. Additionally, it includes a considerable amount of Featured articles from the English Wikipedia, to showcase the best of our work. Most importantly, it comprises more than a year of work by Wikipedians and Linterweb, across countries, oceans and continents. The release is, as Wikipedia, released under the GNU Free Documentation License, version 1.2, with the same conditions Wikipedia articles contain in their respective licenses. Kiwix, the reader software, is released under the GNU General Public License. Most importantly, a portion of the sales will go directly to the Wikimedia Foundation.

Putting this into perspective, Jimbo Wales first put his ideas for "Pushing to 1.0" on August 20, 2003. From there, Jimbo's proposal was discussed, but overall nothing happened: Jimbo's ideas remained mostly in limbo. Now, fast forward to November 20, 2004: Maureen creates the Version 1.0 Editorial Team, and work begins at a slow pace. Originally, work is done by small groups selecting articles; several of these lists still exist, such as the Core Topics list and the Core Topics supplement. However, at around the same time, another part of the team decided to begin work in a test version, to give us lessons as we kept pushing to Version 1.0.

The work on Version 0.5 began on the first week of May 2006, with the creation of the V0.5 nominations page. Nominations actually began on May 23, 2006, and from there, the rest is history. Nowadays, the Version 1.0 Editorial Team is a healthy project, with dozens of dedicated editors. But we didn't have anything to show for our work. I'm glad to be able to say that now, that has changed.

Consider some of the consequences of having a published version of Wikipedia: all of a sudden, you can say for sure what is going to be in a Wikipedia article at the moment you need it. You can point to the CD, and say that this is the revision you obtained your data from. Let's take that analysis even further--you can point to the CD, and say "I wrote this." Isn't that a great feeling? Doesn't that motivate you to write or improve even more articles? However, there is something much more important. Consider Jimbo's personal statement of our vision as Wikimedians:

"Reporters are always asking me why I’m doing this, why Wikipedians do this? I think you know why.

"I can’t speak for everyone, but I can speak for myself. I’m doing this for the child in Africa who is going to use free textbooks and reference works produced by our community and find a solution to the crushing poverty that surrounds him. But for this child, a website on the Internet is not enough; we need to find ways to get our work to people in a form they can actually use."

This is a small step, but a step nonetheless, that will get us closer to that direction. Please take a look at the CD - it will be available for purchase via http://www.wikipediaondvd.com/, for a cost of ~€12 ($15 USD, £8.50). You will also be able to download a copy of the CD's ISO file, both from a mirror and in BitTorrent format.

Either way, as the number "0.5" indicates, we are not done; static releases, just like Wikipedia itself, are not finished, as they are works in progress. We're starting work on Version 0.7 soon, and as everything else on Wikipedia, "more eyes are always more better" (I know that is bad grammar, but that's intentional ;) ). After v0.7, if things go as planned, we intend to finally publish Wikipedia Version 1.0 and accomplish our goal. Then there's also the whole idea of WikiReaders that we are beginning to consider. Overall, the future looks promising. :)

As part of the Version 1.0 Editorial Team, I hope that you will enjoy and use our work, and we hope to provide you with more news of this kind very soon.

Sincerely,

Titoxd.

~~~~

Friday, March 23, 2007

And for some big news....

Tito's note: This is the third in a series of articles about the Version 1.0 Editorial Team in the English Wikipedia.

Let's say that we have some big news...

A static release of Wikipedia is now a reality. :)

Copying the words of Martin Walker, the WP:1.0 coordinator for Version 0.5:

Assuming there are no last minute hitches, the
Wikipedia:Version 0.5 CD should be going on sale on March 26 at www.wikipediaondvd.com for around 10 Euros/$US13-14 (a portion goes to the Foundation). It will also be made available for free download. It consists of 1964 articles and a set of navigation pages, with an open source (GPL) search engine, Kiwix, developed by Linterweb. We now have an ongoing collaboration with Wikimedia France, and User:Kelson wrote many of the scripts for Version 0.5. This CD will make a great birthday present for your loved one! Walkerma 05:54, 22 March 2007 (UTC)

Remember that this is a *test* release. Please check it out, have a look at it, and give us feedback about it.

By the way, all of the articles included in Version 0.5 will be available in Version 0.7, which is being prepared right now. So come join the Version 1.0 Editorial Team to help out!

~~~~